Unveiling the Secrets of Plato’s Closet: Shopping, Selling, and Saving

In the quest for an all-encompassing evaluation of Plato’s Closet, you’ve stumbled upon precisely the right domain. Now, you might ponder, “Why should I lend credence to your perspective?” Well, my involvement with Plato’s Closet extends across a span of nearly a decade. Throughout this duration, I’ve frequented myriad establishments situated across diverse states, and I’ve even had the privilege of laboring there for a substantial four-year period. Hence, it’s safe to assert that I’ve had a prime vantage point to the complete Plato’s Closet expedition – both from a patron’s vantage and in the capacity of an employee.

This distinctive odyssey of mine has imparted insights into the nuances of patronizing Plato’s Closet and the inner workings that transpire when you’re a constituent of their workforce. Consequently, I stand prepared to offer you an authentic, first-person narrative concerning what awaits when you set foot inside a Plato’s Closet emporium.


Plato’s Closet operates by purchasing items from its customers, which is where it all begins. If you’ve got some gently used items tucked away in your closet, it’s definitely worth thinking about bringing them to Plato’s Closet to sell.


This fashion retailer is quite versatile when it comes to what they accept. You can bring in clothing, shoes, purses, hats, jewelry, scarves, and various other accessories. They’re even open to some beauty items. So, if you’ve got a collection of these items, just bag them up and take a trip to your closest Plato’s Closet store.


Once you hand over your items, a Plato’s Closet employee will give them a close look to decide whether or not they can accept them. The amount you’ll receive for each item hinges on a few factors like the brand, style, and the item’s condition.

On average, you can anticipate earning around 30% of the price Plato’s Closet tags your item with. You will therefore receive around $3 for an item if they decide to sell it at $10. Now, I see why Plato’s Closet frequently has a dubious image. Some consumers leave with the impression that they weren’t given the best bargain.

But take a look at this from a different angle. You’ll probably make more money selling to Plato’s Closet than if you simply dropped off your items at a thrift shop. Plus, you’ve got the option to potentially make more money by listing your items on an online marketplace like Poshmark. However, keep in mind that listing each piece individually takes more time and effort.

Last but not least, you can always turn down the offer Plato’s Closet makes to you if you’re not delighted with it. Just calmly inform them that you’d want to have your stuff returned if it’s not what you were looking for. Finding the ideal mix between convenience and value is key.


One of the common gripes about Plato’s Closet is that many sellers believe they have quality items but can’t figure out why their stuff wasn’t accepted. If you find yourself in this situation, don’t hesitate to ask the employee why they didn’t take your items. It’s a straightforward way to get some clarity.

Now, here’s the thing – the buying process, despite their attempts to regulate it, can be somewhat subjective. It often depends on who’s doing the evaluation and accepting the items. That’s why it’s worth noting that you can try another Plato’s Closet store. These franchise locations are individually owned small businesses, so the rules can vary.

In my experience, there were times when our store ended up with an excess of certain items. For instance, we might have too many long-sleeved shirts in stock, which led to a temporary halt on accepting them, regardless of the brand, condition, or style.

It’s essential to understand that the individuals evaluating and buying your clothing items aren’t to blame. They’re just following the guidelines set by higher management when it comes to selecting and accepting specific items and brands. Plus, it’s the computer system that calculates the prices. All the Plato’s Closet worker does is input the type of item, brand, and condition, and the price pops up.

In a nutshell, selling clothes at Plato’s Closet can be a bit of a hit or miss experience, and the process and acceptance rates can vary from one location to another.


Now, let’s dive into the shopping experience in our Plato’s Closet review. We’ll cover the kinds of items you can discover, pricing, and some savvy shopping strategies.


As you step inside Plato’s Closet, you’ll immediately notice the clear division between the women’s and men’s sections. What’s even better is that everything is thoughtfully organized by size and color. It’s a shopper’s dream because you can quickly find exactly what you’re looking for without endless searching.

Take a glance, and you’ll see the shoes smartly displayed on shelves above the clothing racks, with handy signs indicating the shoe sizes for each section.

And don’t forget to explore the endcaps and various scattered racks throughout the store. You’ll stumble upon specialty items, from popular brands like a dedicated Lululemon rack to themed displays for upcoming events like Fourth of July, back to school, or New Year’s Eve.

If you spot styled items and accessories on mannequins gracing the walls or in the window display and you’re interested in them, just ask! Everything on display is up for grabs, and an employee can easily fetch it for you.

Keep an eye out for items placed behind the counter; these tend to be higher-end pieces such as designer purses, expensive shoes, and jewelry. Much like the display mannequins, if you fancy something from there, don’t hesitate to inquire with an employee.

In general, Plato’s Closet offers a mix of casual and trendy items. You can find everyday loungewear, weekend wear, and work-appropriate outfits. However, it’s not the place to hunt for dress shirts, gowns, or formal attire.

What truly sets Plato’s Closet apart is the chance to uncover hidden gems at significantly discounted prices. It’s an excellent destination for budget-conscious shoppers looking for fashionable and affordable clothing options.


Plato’s Closet is committed to being inclusive and caters to all shapes and sizes. They accept and sell items across a broad size spectrum. For women, you can find sizes from 00 all the way up to 22, while for men, sizes range from 26 to 42 waist.

It’s great that Plato’s Closet offers both men’s and women’s sizes, spanning from XXS to 4XL. However, it’s worth noting that the plus-size section may not always be as extensive as other size ranges. Yet, they’re actively working to expand this section to offer more variety to their customers. In fact, plus-size clothing is highly sought after when folks decide to sell their clothes.

The men’s section, too, can sometimes be on the smaller side. Just like with plus-size clothing, most stores are on the lookout for more men’s inventory to keep their offerings diverse and appealing.


Plato’s Closet proudly boasts that they offer items at a generous 70% off the retail price. Keep in mind, though, that the actual discounts can vary. Nevertheless, you’ll often stumble upon some incredible deals and substantial markdowns.

To give you a rough idea, here’s a typical pricing range for various item types, although it’s crucial to remember that prices can fluctuate significantly depending on the brand.

  • Dresses: $8-$12
  • Tops: $5-$10
  • Jeans: $12-$30
  • Coats and Jackets: $12-$24
  • Athleticwear: $5-$30
  • Shoes: $10-$40

At Plato’s Closet, you can uncover some well-loved gems like Lululemon leggings for a steal, usually in the range of $24 to $40. And if you’re a fan of Patagonia, you’re in for a treat because their jackets and pullovers often go for around $30 to $40.

I had this one fortunate find – a Patagonia Nanopuff coat for just $30. Unfortunately, it didn’t quite fit me, but I turned it into a sweet profit by reselling it for a cool $134 through my online resale business.

If you’re keen on the idea of flipping and reselling items from Plato’s Closet, we’ve got a helpful guide on Poshmark for beginners that you should definitely check out. It’s a fantastic platform for getting into the reselling game.


No comprehensive Plato’s Closet review would be complete without spilling the beans on how to score even deeper discounts on their already super affordable items.


You’re in for an extra treat because nearly all Plato’s Closet locations offer discounts through the Fivestars app.

Here’s the deal: When you sign up on the Fivestars app using your phone number, you’ll link it to your Plato’s Closet account. This nifty connection lets you earn points every time you shop at Plato’s.

Now, the precise program and point-earning potential can vary from store to store, so it’s worth checking with your local branch. However, you can typically rack up points to snag sweet deals like $5 off, $10 off, or a percentage discount like 10% or 20% off your purchase.

The best part? Signing up is a breeze, and all you need to do is provide your phone number at the checkout. It’s a fantastic way to make your Plato’s Closet shopping even more budget-friendly.


Here’s another neat trick to keep your savings rolling at Plato’s Closet – the shopping promo card, often referred to as a coupon card. These little gems are distributed in one month and are good for use in the following month.

For example, in my local Plato’s Closet, they recently had a promotion where if you made a purchase in April, you’d get a coupon card that could slice $5.01 off any purchase in May.

These coupon cards are like gold because there’s no minimum purchase requirement to snag one. Plus, there’s no minimum spend to use the card in the following month. So, imagine this: You buy a piece of jewelry for just a few dollars in April, and voila, you’re handed a coupon card for May. When May comes around, you find something worth $5, and it’s basically free!

Many stores let you stockpile as many coupon cards as you can. The only catch is that you can use just one coupon card per transaction when it’s time to cash in on your savings in the following month. So, if you’re a savvy shopper, these coupon cards can be a fantastic way to score some fantastic deals.


If you’re on the hunt for even more ways to grab discounts and some extra “closet cash” to splurge at Plato’s Closet, keep an eye out for their contests. To get in on the action, make sure you’re following your local Plato’s Closet on social media.

You’ll often find them running contests, giveaways, and dishing out gift cards or store vouchers. This is a common practice, especially in anticipation of holidays or special sale days. So, if you’re a fan of extra savings, staying connected with your local store on social media is a smart move.



One of the highlights for Plato’s Closet shoppers is the eagerly awaited Dollar Days sale. This event usually unfolds over a weekend and has bargain-hunters all abuzz.

During this sale, clearance items are stacked into bins both outside and around the store, with a fixed price tag of just $1 for each item. While it’s still possible to uncover some hidden treasures and essential pieces, it’s worth noting that these Dollar Days items were all part of the clearance section, significantly marked down, and didn’t find buyers in their previous rounds.


In recent times, Plato’s Closet has upped its sale game, offering something even better than Dollar Days. These new sales often focus on specific categories of items.

For instance, at my local Plato’s Closet, they ran a jaw-dropping $2 dress sale. What’s really mind-blowing is that this deal covered ALL dresses in the store, not just the clearance items! Let’s just say, I went a little wild during that sale and ended up with over 100 dresses – no regrets here.

I’ve also seen similar promotions like $2 long sleeves, coats, jackets, and pants sales, and even a $3 athleticwear sale. To stay in the loop and not miss out on these fantastic deals, make sure to follow your local Plato’s Closet on social media. It’s the best way to be the first to know when these sales are coming your way.


Plato’s Closet hosts another crowd-pleaser – the totes sale. During this event, they hand out tote bags to every customer. You get to roam the store and load up your tote with as many goodies as you can fit in it.

Here’s the sweet part: you get a solid 30% discount on each item you manage to squeeze inside that bag. It’s like a shopping spree with a built-in discount, and it’s no wonder it’s a hit among Plato’s Closet regulars.


Plato’s Closet often rolls out fun and exciting holiday-themed sales. Take Easter, for example. During this time, customers get to enjoy a mystery discount sale that adds a touch of excitement to their shopping experience.

Here’s how it works: Shoppers pick out their items and head to the cash register to check out. But just before they pay, they pick an egg, and inside lies a mystery discount. The discounts typically range from 10% to 30%, and there’s even a chance that one lucky customer might snag an egg that grants them their entire purchase for FREE!

So, as you can see, there are plenty of creative ways to save big while having a blast at Plato’s Closet. It’s all part of what makes shopping there such a delightful experience.


Plato’s Closet does offer a return policy, but there are some important details to keep in mind. You’ve got a 7-day window to return clothing items, and it’s crucial that you show up with the original receipt. Additionally, the tags must still be attached; if they’re not, the return may not be accepted. This is because without the tags, there’s no surefire way to confirm that the item hasn’t been worn. If your return is valid and approved, you’ll have the option to receive store credit or get your money back.

However, there are certain items marked as “final sale” that can’t be returned. These typically include:

  • Any clearance item (clothing included)
  • Shoes
  • Purses
  • Wallets
  • Scarves
  • Jewelry
  • Any other accessory

Hence, it’s a wise move to give your shoes and other accessories a thorough once-over before making your purchase at Plato’s Closet.


This comprehensive article delves into the world of Plato’s Closet, offering insights into both selling and shopping experiences at this popular thrift store chain. With a unique perspective gained from nearly a decade of involvement, the author covers the process of selling items at Plato’s Closet, what to expect when shopping there, pricing, discounts, sales, and their return policy. The article aims to provide readers with a thorough understanding of what awaits when they step inside a Plato’s Closet store.

Facts about Plato’s Closet:

  • Plato’s Closet is a popular thrift store chain known for buying and selling gently used clothing and accessories.
  • The store accepts a wide range of items, including clothing, shoes, purses, hats, jewelry, scarves, and beauty items.
  • The amount you receive for your items when selling to Plato’s Closet depends on factors such as brand, style, and item condition.
  • On average, sellers can expect to earn around 30% of the price Plato’s Closet tags their items with.
  • Plato’s Closet stores are individually owned small businesses, which can lead to variations in the acceptance of items and pricing.
  • If Plato’s Closet doesn’t accept your items, you can ask the employees for feedback on why they weren’t accepted.
  • Plato’s Closet offers a well-organized shopping experience with sections for women and men, organized by size and color.
  • The store often features specialty items, themed displays, and high-end items behind the counter.
  • Plato’s Closet carries a mix of casual and trendy clothing, making it a great place for budget-conscious shoppers.
  • The store caters to a broad range of sizes, from 00 to 22 for women and 26 to 42 waist for men.
  • Prices at Plato’s Closet are typically 70% off the retail price, but they can vary depending on the brand.
  • Plato’s Closet offers additional discounts through the Fivestars app, where customers can earn points for future purchases.
  • The store also provides coupon cards that can be used to get discounts on future purchases.
  • Plato’s Closet frequently runs contests and giveaways on social media, offering gift cards and store vouchers.
  • Dollar Days and $1, $2, $3 clothing item sales are popular events at Plato’s Closet, allowing customers to find incredible bargains.
  • The “totes” sale offers a 30% discount on items that fit inside a provided tote bag.
  • Holiday sales, such as mystery discount sales during Easter, add excitement to the shopping experience.
  • Plato’s Closet has a 7-day return policy for clothing items with the original receipt and tags attached.
  • Some items, like clearance items, shoes, purses, and jewelry, may be marked as “final sale” and cannot be returned.
  • Plato’s Closet provides a unique shopping experience for those looking for affordable, fashionable, and sustainable clothing options.

 FAQ about Plato’s Closet:

What kind of items does Plato’s Closet accept for selling?

Plato’s Closet accepts clothing, shoes, purses, hats, jewelry, scarves, and some beauty items. They focus on gently used and stylish items.

How is the selling process at Plato’s Closet determined?

Plato’s Closet employees evaluate items based on factors like brand, style, and condition to determine their purchase price.

Can I negotiate the price offered by Plato’s Closet for my items?

The prices Plato’s Closet offers are typically non-negotiable, but you can choose to decline their offer if it’s not satisfactory.

Is it possible to return items purchased at Plato’s Closet?

Yes, Plato’s Closet has a 7-day return policy for clothing items with the original receipt and tags attached.

How does the Fivestars app work for earning discounts at Plato’s Closet?

By signing up for the Fivestars app, you can earn points on your purchases at Plato’s Closet, which can be redeemed for discounts on future purchases.

What are the typical prices for different types of clothing items at Plato’s Closet?

Prices at Plato’s Closet are typically around 70% off the retail price, but they can vary depending on the brand and item type.

How often do Plato’s Closet stores have sales or discount events?

Plato’s Closet regularly hosts sales events like Dollar Days, category-specific sales, and holiday-themed sales.

Are there any restrictions on items that can be returned to Plato’s Closet?

Certain items, marked as “final sale,” like clearance items, shoes, purses, and jewelry, cannot be returned.

What is the most popular size range available at Plato’s Closet?

Plato’s Closet caters to a broad size range, but plus-size clothing and some men’s sizes may have a smaller selection.

How can I stay updated on Plato’s Closet sales and promotions in my area?

Follow your local Plato’s Closet store on social media to stay informed about sales, contests, and giveaways.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *